US House committee looking into roadside survey - KNOE 8 News; KNOE-TV; KNOE.com |

US House committee looking into roadside survey

Posted: Updated:
Source: MGN Online Source: MGN Online

WASHINGTON, D.C. (KNOE 8 News) - The chairman of the House transportation committee said Thursday he wants to make sure a federal roadside survey on drinking and drugged driving is being conducted appropriately after motorists complained about being forced off the road and asked to provide breath, blood and saliva samples.

Rep. Bill Shuster said his committee will investigate the National Roadside Survey of Alcohol and Drugged Driving, the government's periodic effort to determine how many of the nation's motorists are driving while drunk or high.

"While over the years this survey has provided valuable highway safety information, the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee is looking into this issue, and we want to ensure that it is being conducted in an appropriate manner," Shuster, R-Pa., told The Associated Press.

The survey has been conducted five times since 1973. U.S. transportation officials call it a vital tool for monitoring the safety of America's roadways, and groups like Mothers Against Drunk Driving and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety support it. But some motorists and civil liberties advocates contend the government's methods are intrusive and unconstitutional.

Conducted in 60 cities around the nation, the survey yields the government's best estimate of the prevalence of impaired driving. Motorists are randomly selected - either by a uniformed police officer or a private contractor working for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration - and waved into a parking lot, where they are questioned about their drinking and driving habits, asked to take a breath test and offered money if they provide saliva and blood samples or agree to answer a more extensive written survey.

Federal officials stress the survey is voluntary and anonymous, with survey respondents who are found to be impaired either driven home or put up in a hotel.

The AP reported last month that concerns about the study date at least as far back as 2007, with a survey methodology describing the tactics used by the Calverton, Md.-based contractor, the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, as "not routine by any means." In November, the police chief of Fort Worth, Texas, apologized for his officers' role in the survey and said it wouldn't happen again.

Other members of Congress also expressed concern in the wake of the AP report.

"It is imperative that we do what we can to ensure that our roads are safe from impaired drivers," said Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa. "My constituents have raised some legitimate concerns about the tactics used in the administration of these roadside surveys. NHTSA needs to make sure that their efforts are in accordance with the law and that they take care to protect the rights of Pennsylvanians and drivers across the country while they do the important work of keeping our roads safe."

Rep. Lou Barletta, R-Pa., who sits on the transportation committee, said he'd like to consider "different methods we can use to best collect this lifesaving data, while also ensuring privacy rights are protected."

In Reading, Pa., motorist Ricardo Nieves has filed suit over the survey, saying his rights were violated when a Pacific Institute employee forced him into a parking lot, where he was questioned about his driving habits and asked to provide a saliva sample. He refused and drove away.

Nieves had asked a judge to issue a preliminary injunction against the city of Reading and the contractor. A hearing was scheduled for Friday, but attorneys on both sides asked the judge to cancel it after the Pacific Institute - whose survey work was scheduled to wrap up last month anyway - agreed it would not conduct any additional surveys in eastern Pennsylvania for the duration of the lawsuit.

Nieves is still seeking a permanent ban on the survey, as well as damages from the Dec. 13 stop itself. The Pacific Institute has asked a judge to throw out the lawsuit.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • 28 Monroe area businesses cited for selling to minors

    28 Monroe area businesses cited for selling to minors

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 11:51 AM EDT2014-07-29 15:51:09 GMT
    Baton Rouge, La. (KNOE 8 News ATC) - Agents with the Office of Alcohol and Tobacco Control recently conducted compliance checks at 173 businesses in the Monroe and West Monroe areas. During those compliance checks, 28 of the businesses, which consist of area restaurants, bars and convenience stores, were caught selling alcohol and tobacco products to minors.
    Baton Rouge, La. (KNOE 8 News ATC) - Agents with the Office of Alcohol and Tobacco Control recently conducted compliance checks at 173 businesses in the Monroe and West Monroe areas. During those compliance checks, 28 of the businesses, which consist of area restaurants, bars and convenience stores, were caught selling alcohol and tobacco products to minors.
  • K9 Officer helps nab Ruston robbery suspects

    K9 Officer helps nab Ruston robbery suspects

    Monday, July 28 2014 11:29 AM EDT2014-07-28 15:29:21 GMT
    RUSTON, La. (KNOE 8 News Ruston Police) - Two robbery suspects are in custody after leading several Ruston Police Officers and a K9 Officer on a chase through town.
    RUSTON, La. (KNOE 8 News Ruston Police) - Two robbery suspects are in custody after leading several Ruston Police Officers and a K9 Officer on a chase through town.
  • Union Sheriff: Man was attempting to hire hit man to kill family members

    Union Sheriff: Man was attempting to hire hit man to kill family members

    Monday, July 28 2014 1:21 PM EDT2014-07-28 17:21:58 GMT
    UNION PARISH, La. (KNOE 8 News UPSO) - A Ouachita Parish resident was arrested by Union Parish sheriff’s deputies and investigators over the weekend accused of solicitation of murder.
    UNION PARISH, La. (KNOE 8 News UPSO) - A Ouachita Parish resident was arrested by Union Parish sheriff’s deputies and investigators over the weekend accused of solicitation of murder.
  • Two arrests, officer tazed at Watermelon Festival

    Two arrests, officer tazed at Watermelon Festival

    Monday, July 28 2014 4:41 PM EDT2014-07-28 20:41:59 GMT
    FARMERVILLE, La. (KNOE 8 News UPSO) - Union Parish sheriff’s deputies made at least two arrests over the Watermelon Festival weekend, one that involved a deputy getting tazed.
    FARMERVILLE, La. (KNOE 8 News UPSO) - Union Parish sheriff’s deputies made at least two arrests over the Watermelon Festival weekend, one that involved a deputy getting tazed.
  • West Monroe man arrested for meth possession

    West Monroe man arrested for meth possession

    Sunday, July 27 2014 9:09 PM EDT2014-07-28 01:09:38 GMT
    WEST MONROE, La. (KNOE 8 News) - West Monroe Police arrested a man early Sunday morning for possession of drugs.
    WEST MONROE, La. (KNOE 8 News) - West Monroe Police arrested a man early Sunday morning for possession of drugs.
  • Homeowners don't want rehab built in their backyards

    Monday, July 28 2014 7:46 PM EDT2014-07-28 23:46:45 GMT
    MONROE, La. (KNOE 8 News) - Not in my back yard! That's what some homeowners in rural Ouachita Parish are saying about a rehab facility being built in their neighborhood. They've voiced their concerns to the Ouachita Parish Police Jury, but say they haven't gotten anywhere. 
    MONROE, La. (KNOE 8 News) - Not in my back yard! That's what some homeowners in rural Ouachita Parish are saying about a rehab facility being built in their neighborhood. They've voiced their concerns to the Ouachita Parish Police Jury, but say they haven't gotten anywhere. 
  • Clerk wrestles gun away from armed robbery suspect

    Clerk wrestles gun away from armed robbery suspect

    Saturday, July 26 2014 4:40 PM EDT2014-07-26 20:40:24 GMT
    MONROE, La. (KNOE 8 News) - Police are investigating an attempted armed robbery where a clerk fought a gun away from a suspect.
    MONROE, La. (KNOE 8 News) - Police are investigating an attempted armed robbery where a clerk fought a gun away from a suspect.
  • A second person has died from emergency plane landing on beach

    A second person has died from emergency plane landing on beach

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 12:06 PM EDT2014-07-29 16:06:21 GMT
    A second person has died from Sunday's emergency plane landing on a Florida beach.
    A second person has died from Sunday's emergency plane landing on a Florida beach.
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KNOE. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.